Court Verdict on Manna Storehouse Food Coop; Results of a SWAT-like Team Raid on a Family Mini-Farm

The SWAT-like team raid in December 2008 of a food coop called the Manna Storehouse near LaGrange, Ohio (Lorain County) was heavily covered here at the Journal. Sheriff deputies and agents from Ohio Department of Agriculture and the county health department stormed the home while homeschool was in session with several children and were held at bay in a room for seven hours while agents confiscated food, computers and records. They did not obtain a food service license after it was requested by the health department. After a court ruling earlier that Manna required a food service license from the health department, owners John and Jaqueline Stowers appealed. Yesterday, the verdict on the appeal was that Manna is a retail store and must be licensed, according to the Lorain Morning Journal newspaper:

  • Appellate judges ruled yesterday the Manna Storehouse, a LaGrange organic food co-op, is a retail store, and as such is not exempt from Ohio food safety regulations and should be licensed.
  • The ruling upheld a Feb. 10, 2010, decision by Lorain County Common Pleas Judge James Burge that despite Jacqueline and John Stowers’ claim that their organic food store on SR 303 was not a retail store, it is subject to inspection and regulation.
  • The Stowers also argued the regulatory ruling about licensing “infringes upon property rights, their right to earn a livelihood, their freedom to contract, and their inherent natural right to cooperate with friends and neighbors to acquire food” as guaranteed in the constitution.
  • Appellate judges also state the storehouse does not fall under the category of an exempted storehouse, such as a farm or market.
  • The controversy surrounding the Manna Storehouse started when the Ohio Department of Agriculture raided the store in 2008 and confiscated hundreds of pounds of processed beef and large amounts of lamb, turkey and other perishable products in addition to office files, a computer, two cell phones and other electronic devices, according to the search warrant inventory.
  • The items were taken to establish the Stowers’ ownership in any property, records of hidden wealth or illegal income and anything that would establish illegal activity, according to the search warrant affidavit.

The Stowers filed some 70 complaints to the federal court, among them: claiming unlawful search and seizure, violation of equal protection and due process, unlawful exercise of administrative authority, unlawful application of state police power, violation of inalienable and retained rights and taking advantage of private property without compensation– but the suit was dropped and taken into a state court and the court ruled in favor of the state and this prompted the appeal.

9 responses to “Court Verdict on Manna Storehouse Food Coop; Results of a SWAT-like Team Raid on a Family Mini-Farm

  1. The court and legal proceeding missed the entire point: the all too frequent monstrous and overblown abusive action –and on such a petty matter.

  2. Hopefully this was well covered by the media locally. It’s too bad we don’t hear about these kinds of ridiculous, overblown raids in the mainstream.

  3. man, this sucks — even when we form co-ops or private buying clubs to acquire the food we want, the government asserts its claws into our own private business matters.

  4. Fascism trumps freedom of association. Who needs a Constitution, anyway?

  5. I hope they are appealing to a higher court? The Federal Govt is out of Control. They want us all dumbed down and on Phara drugs. I only hope we grow in size to fight these Bastards.

  6. Pingback: Podcast: Mr. Augie on Raw Milk | The Ohio Public Square

  7. “Appellate judges also state the storehouse does not fall under the category of an exempted storehouse, such as a farm or market”
    If they want the farm or market exemption, then they should proceed in adhering to whatever those guidelines are. Since most of us posting on here don’t like the way our laws seem to be infringing upon our rights, we should proceed in adhering to whatever the guidelines are to re-write the laws.
    Myself, I would be just fine living in a peaceful anarchy. Government becomes corrupt and too big and bingo – we have the mess we have.

  8. Pingback: Farmageddon – The Unseen War on American Family Farms | Modern Serenity

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s